Carburizing, carbonitriding and other case-hardening treatments appear on some made-to-print fastener and pin drawings. When the current revision calls them up, the process, the case depth, the surface hardness and any core hardness or microstructure requirement belong in the agreed route and in the inspection plan. They are not an informal shop hardening used to “make the thread last longer”, and they are not assumed from a grade name such as 1010 or 10B21, or from a property class that is usually met by through-hardening.

SUNHY reviews a specified case treatment on bolts, screws and studs, on turned parts and on pins or special shafts, against the customer drawing. The notes on heat treatment, on carbon and alloy steels and on hardness and tensile checks belong beside this one. This article looks at what a case-hardening call-out should make visible, and at how it should be written in an RFQ.

The print has to name the treatment and the result

A complete call-out names the process or the required case (carburized, carbonitrided, or a customer process specification), the case depth or the effective case, the surface hardness, and any core hardness, microstructure, or white-layer limit. “Case harden” or “hardening to wear” without those figures is not complete. If a customer heat-treatment specification already exists, it should be named on the revision or attached to the enquiry. A property class that is usually associated with through-hardened fasteners is not rewritten as a case-hardening requirement, or the reverse.

The starting grade has to be consistent with the treatment. A steel that is specified for through-hardening to a high class, and a steel that is specified for a shallow case, are not interchangeable just because both can be headed. Grade substitutions, including a change to or from a boron steel, are specification changes, as already described in the note on carbon and alloy steels. Masking, if a thread, a shank or a head must remain soft, is a stated requirement, not an informal shop practice.

Sequence, distortion and later changes

Case hardening sits in a sequence with heading or machining, any intermediate anneal, threading, and coating. That sequence is part of the agreed route and is stated rather than assumed. Threads may be produced before or after the case, with different effects on form, gauge and residual stress. A sample that was through-hardened, or that was left soft, is not approval of a later case-hardened route, or the reverse. A change of process, of case depth, or of the position of the treatment in the sequence is a process change and is re-validated before serial release — see the notes on prototype samples and series production and on secondary operations.

Distortion, growth and any subsequent straightening, grinding or thread sizing belong in the review when the geometry makes them relevant. They are documented, not informal. Intermediate softening, if it is used to make heading or machining possible before the case, is also documented, as described in the note on annealing and in-process softening.

Coating and hydrogen-embrittlement control

A case-hardened surface can be sensitive to a subsequent coating, particularly where a high surface hardness and a residual-stress state are present. If a coating is specified, any hydrogen-embrittlement control is named with that coating and confirmed per order when required, as already described in the existing coatings note. Informal baking, or a change of coating “because the case makes plating difficult”, is not a made-to-print practice.

The finished thread still has to meet the class of fit and any useful-length or gauging condition, including after coating if required. Over-tapping or a change from rolling to cutting after case trials is a process decision that must follow the print. Those thread rules are the same as in the notes on thread gauging and on rolled versus cut threads.

Inspection of the case

Surface hardness, case depth, core hardness, microstructure, and any decarburization or white-layer check are used when the print or the order requires that evidence, not automatically in every possible form. The location of a hardness reading matters; a reading on a thread flank, on a shank and on a head are not interchangeable. If a particular method, a micro-section, or a first-article report is already decided, name it. A file test or a “it feels hard” check is not a substitute for a case depth that is written on the print.

Certificates and any EN 10204 3.1 or heat-treatment report are confirmed per order when required, as in the notes on material grade and certificates and on order documents. First-article inspection, when required, should be planned on the production-intent route, including the case-hardening and coating sequence. That rule is the same as in the note on first-article inspection.

What to write in the RFQ

Quote the case-hardening process or specification, the case depth, the surface and core hardness, any masking, the material grade, the thread and coating requirements, the documents you need, the volume and the rest of the part as they appear on the current revision. Send the print with the request form, not a request to “harden the surface” without figures.

Send the print. The scope is confirmed before quote.

Email the current drawing revision, or use the request form. Unspecified points will be flagged before production rather than assumed.

This article is a capability and commercial note. It is not a certificate, a dimensional data book, or evidence of customer approval. Catalogue type codes and example grades do not replace the customer’s item number, material specification or drawing revision.