A 3D model is often useful when reviewing a housing, a stub, a special nut or another made-to-print part: it helps the reading of form, the discussion of tool access, and the preparation of a machining or heading study. On SUNHY’s made-to-print orders the 2D drawing remains the authority for dimensions, tolerances, notes, material and finish, unless the enquiry or the order says in writing that a model, or a model-based definition, is the authority. The current revision of that authority has to be identified, as in the note on Drawing revision control on made-to-print orders.
What has to be stated when a model is supplied
If a model is sent with the RFQ, the enquiry should name the file, the revision or date, the units, and the relationship to the 2D drawing: supporting data, equivalent data, or an agreed authority. If only a model is sent, that should be said plainly, because many characteristics — roughness, coating, gauging, notes — still live on a 2D sheet or in a referenced specification. “Use the CAD” is not complete.
Tolerances are not inferred from a modelled nominal. Reference dimensions, basic dimensions and inspected characteristics are read from the drawing scheme, as in the note on Reference dimensions versus inspected characteristics. Datum schemes and geometric tolerances are taken from the 2D feature-control frames unless a written model-based scheme has been agreed, as in the note on Datums and geometric tolerances on turned parts.
Conflicts between model and drawing
When a model and a 2D revision disagree — a different fillet, a missing chamfer, a wall that is thicker in the model than on the sheet — the conflict is flagged. It is not resolved by choosing the easier shape on the machine. Unless a written order of precedence says otherwise, the 2D revision is used, and the customer is asked to correct the model or the drawing. The same approach is used for other specification-stack conflicts in the note on Specification stack and order of precedence.
A rendered photograph, a scan of a sample, or a competitor’s model is not a drawing. Those files can support a discussion; they do not authorise production. A family of similar parts needs a current authority for each item number; one model is not a licence to invent the next length, as in the note on Quoting a family of similar parts.
Route, first article and tooling
CAM programs, electrode design, or heading-tool studies may start from the model, but first-article inspection, when required, reports the part against the agreed authority, as in the note on First-article inspection on made-to-print parts. A tool cut from an outdated model is a process-control problem, not a reason to change the print. If the model is later updated without a drawing revision, that update is not assumed to be the new authority.
What the model does not claim
A model of a stub, a housing or a set of internals is still a model of component parts. It is not a model of an approved regulator, filter or station, and it does not imply a PED assembly. Machining to the agreed authority produces the part; it does not approve the customer’s device.
Units, geometry that only exists in one file, and CAM
A model built in inches and a drawing issued in millimetres, or a model whose origin does not match the drawing datums, will generate silent errors in CAM and in inspection programs. Units, the coordinate system and the datum origin should be checked at review, not discovered when a first-article length is systematically short. Threads, draft, spark gaps and “simplified” holes that exist only as cosmetic features in the model are called out so that they are not machined as metal.
If a tool path is generated from the model, the inspection still reports the 2D authority unless a written model-based scheme has been agreed. A beautiful tool path that follows a model fillet which the drawing does not allow is a nonconformance, not a process improvement. When both files are updated, they should be issued together, with the same revision identity or with a stated cross-reference, so that the shop is not left to guess which pair belongs together.
Supplier-created models, including those made to help a quote or a fixture design, remain working files unless the customer adopts them in writing. They are not issued as a competing authority. If a fixture or a gauge is designed from such a working model, the inspection of the part still reports the official 2D revision, and any mismatch found in that exercise is raised as a drawing or model question, not absorbed into the fixture as a hidden compensation.
If a revision of the drawing is issued without an updated model, or the reverse, production waits for a written statement of which file to follow for the next lot. The older of the two is not kept in CAM “because it already runs”.
What to send with the RFQ
Send the current 2D drawing revision, and the model if it will help the review, with the relationship between them stated. Include material, finish and volume. If the model is to be treated as the authority, or if a model-based definition already exists, say so in writing. Unspecified points will be flagged before production rather than assumed.
This article is a capability and commercial note. It is not a certificate, a dimensional data book, or evidence of customer approval. Catalogue type codes and example grades do not replace the customer’s item number, material specification or drawing revision.